I've been invited by SheepDog Inc. to lead a free webinar on Privacy and Security in the Cloud on August 16, 2011. Full information and the registration form are both available on the event page on the site: Privacy and Security Webinar with David Fraser -- SheepDogInc.ca.
News and commentary on legal aspects of cloud computing from a Canadian perspective.
Thursday, August 11, 2011
Sunday, August 7, 2011
Google announces security certification for Apps and Apps Engine
For business thinking about moving data into the cloud, among the first questions to ask (and they do, trust me) is whether their data will be secure. Google has generally published a lot of information on the security of their enterprise products (including an interesting Whitepaper),
This week, Google announced that it has obtained certification for the next generation of SAS 70, SSAE 16 Type II attestation and its international counterpart, ISAE 3402 Type II. From the Official Google Enterprise Blog: Security First: Google Apps and Google App Engine receive SSAE-16 certification.
Friday, June 10, 2011
Legal issues in cloud computing contracts
Yesterday, IT World Canada published a very lengthy article on the manifold legal issues that need to be considered when a company moves its data to the cloud, including a lengthy interview with me given a little while ago.
Here's the first part ...
Canadian cloud contracts: Liabilities and limitations - Page 1 - Leadership
More companies in Canada are turning to the cloud — or, at least, thinking about it — for flexibility, agility and cost savings. But there is often the perception that using cloud-computing services could compromise corporate and customer data, or may even be against the law.
But there’s no law that prevents most Canadian businesses from exporting personal information, said David Fraser, partner with McInnis Cooper, president of the Canadian IT Law Association and chair of the National Privacy and Access Law Section of the Canadian Bar Association.
“Once you move into a real cloud computing model, all of a sudden you don’t know where your data is — where in Canada or where in the world — and we’ve seen a big privacy-related backlash against cloud computing,” he said. So a large part of his job is telling people they’re wrong, since there’s a huge amount of misinformation out there.
Private-sector privacy laws require that you ensure a comparable level of security for personal information, regardless of whether you permit it to be managed by a Canadian company or a non-Canadian company. And some highly regulated industries, such as banking, have special rules that may include additional regulation for outsourced services.
“The Patriot Act is the big thing that people freak out about,” he said, “but we have a Canadian version of the Patriot Act, which is just as offensive.”
Here’s the deal: In 2001, the U.S. Congress passed the USA Patriot Act, which expanded the powers of law enforcement and national security agencies to carry out investigations and obtain intelligence in connection with anti-terrorism investigations.
But the provisions that have attracted the most criticism, said Fraser, have equivalents under Canadian law. Regardless of where information resides, it will always be subject to lawful disclosure to law enforcement or national security bodies. In Canada, he said, this includes search warrants under the Criminal Code of Canada and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act. Many European countries also permit broader law enforcement and national security access to information than in both the U.S. and Canada.
Of course, where the data sits can have an impact on that data. If it’s in North Korea or China, it’s at high risk, said Fraser. In the U.S., it may in some cases be significant, but in most cases it won’t be. “How interested would the FBI be in getting their hands on that data and would they be able to justify getting a subpoena? In most cases no,” he said. “And if it’s a person of interest they can get it in Canada.”
Many people are surprised to learn there’s a secret court in the U.S. where judges hear applications made by Department of Justice lawyers for search warrants (and other such things) and there’s nobody on the other side to oppose those applications.
“We have a secret court in Canada,” said Fraser. “We have a bunker in Ottawa where judges hear lawyers from the Department of Justice and CSIS for warrants to do things as potentially offensive as break into your house and install wiretapping equipment. These orders can specifically provide for authorities to go back in and change the batteries. So people don’t often think that Canada is engaged in these types of cloak and dagger things, and we are. Our definition of anti-terrorism is as broad and offensive as the U.S.”
Canadian authorities have virtually identical powers under the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act, he said, which permits secret court orders that authorize CSIS to intercept communications or to obtain anything named in the warrant.
On top of that, Canada has a mutual legal assistance treaty with the U.S. (as well as informal agreements), so if the FBI wants data and it’s in the hands of a Canadian company, the FBI calls the RCMP or CSIS. “So when you dig into it, that cross-border issue, at least in most cases, really is not the large issue that many people are led to believe it is,” he said, adding that the Patriot Act has become shorthand for just saying no.
Only British Columbia and Nova Scotia have laws strictly regulating the export of personal information from Canada by public bodies, said Fraser. For all other jurisdictions, including the federal jurisdiction, export is permitted, but the public body must ensure a comparable level of security for personal information, regardless of whether it’s managed by a Canadian or non-Canadian company.
What businesses need to do is benchmark their existing privacy infrastructure and compare it to the privacy infrastructure of the proposed cloud provider. What are the real risks to the data, and to privacy and security? A lot of businesses have significant existing vulnerabilities — from insecure desktops, to playing catch-up with security patches, to mobile employees running around with laptops. Or thumb drives. “Nothing is more stupid or dangerous,” said Fraser. “In a cloud model if the computer is lost you lose nothing.”
Very often, this benchmark leans heavily in favour of the cloud provider that has squadrons of security people. Small businesses, in particular, are vulnerable to power outages and basic continuity issues. A reputable large-scale cloud provider will have multiple data centres, so things will stay up and running.
Saturday, June 4, 2011
Alberta Commissioner seeks leave to appeal Leon's case to the Supreme Court
In April, the Alberta Court of Appeal handed a significant defeat to the Information and Privacy Commissioner in Leon’s Furniture Limited v. Alberta (Information and Privacy Commissioner), 2011 ABCA 94 (CanLII), a case about whether a retailer is justified in collecting drivers' license and license plate information from customers picking up furniture. (See: Canadian Privacy Law Blog: Alberta Court of Appeal overrules province's Commissioner on license info.) Now it appears the Commissioner is taking the case to the Supreme Court of Canada. The application for leave to appeal was filed on May 26. The Court has discretion to determine whether it will hear the appeal, so it will be interesting to see whether the Court determines this to be a matter of national importance.
Thursday, May 26, 2011
Cloud computing presentation to University of Windsor
On May 26, 2011, I had the pleasure of speaking at the University of Windsor's annual Campus Technology Day. Windsor has just recently made the decision to "Go Google" for student e-mail services.
My topic was cloud computing and privacy (with a little bit on copyright thrown in for good measure). Here is the presentation:
There were many active tweeters using #uwctd, in case you're looking for play-by-play commentary.
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Patrick Leahy introduces update to Electronic Communications Privacy Act
Today, May 17, 2011, Patrick Leahy introduced a bill to amend and substantially fix the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA). The bill made sense at the time it was first authored by Leahy a quarter century ago, but it has needed a substantial re-write in this cloud computing age. The most problematic provision allows obtaining stored communications that are more than 180 days old with just a subpoena, rather than a warrant based on probable cause. Twenty-five years ago, you might consider an un-downloaded e-mail message to have been abandoned, but that is no longer the case when millions of users are keeping all of their e-mails and documents in the cloud.
The Digital Due Process Coalition has been heavily lobbying for this change for some time.
For more info: Patrick Leahy introduces update to electronic privacy law - Post Tech - The Washington Post
Friday, May 6, 2011
Canadian Privacy Commissioner releases consultation report on cloud computing and online profiling
The Privacy Commissioner of Canada has just today released her report that resulted from last year's consumer consultations, which focused on cloud computing, online tracking/profiling. The report is here: Report on the 2010 Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada's Consultations on Online Tracking, Profiling and Targeting, and Cloud Computing.
The summary is:
In the spring of 2010, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC) held consultations on online tracking, profiling and targeting, and cloud computing. The OPC received in total 32 written submissions and held public events in Toronto, Montreal and Calgary, attended by representatives of other privacy commissioner offices and industry, as well as academics, advocates and members of the public. On October 25, 2010, the OPC released a draft report on the consultations, seeking further comments on a range of issues, from the public/private divide to cloud computing. Twelve responses were received, addressing some of these issues.
With respect to online tracking, profiling and targeting, we heard primarily about the privacy issues related to behavioural advertising: what it is, what the benefits are, what risks to privacy exist, and what self-regulatory measures are in place. In terms of general privacy concerns, the blurring of the public/private divide and its effects on reputation was seen as a significant issue that arises from online tracking, profiling and targeting. Children's activities online and the need to incorporate privacy into digital citizenship programs were also items that were raised.
The consultations were an opportunity to examine the practices of online tracking, profiling and targeting through the lens of the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA). While most industry participants were of the view that PIPEDA can handle the evolving technological environment, certain challenges with respect to applying the law were raised by many respondents and participants. Defining what is (or is not) personal information, determining the appropriate form of consent, limiting the use of personal information, implementing reasonable safeguards, providing access and correction to online information, and ensuring accountability were cited as PIPEDA-related issues that need careful attention. Online tracking, profiling and targeting are still largely invisible to most individuals, and most respondents and participants agreed that greater transparency is needed for the benefit of individuals and to ensure innovation.
With respect to cloud computing, the OPC learned about the different characteristics and models of cloud computing. We heard about its benefits and risks to enterprises and consumers. Again, most respondents and participants were of the view that PIPEDA can address issues that arise from cloud computing while others suggested that more should be done. Most of the PIPEDA-related issues concerned jurisdiction and availability of personal information to third parties; safeguards; new uses for the personal information and retention; and access.
The OPC is proposing to undertake specific activities in relation to online tracking, profiling and targeting, specifically in terms of research and outreach activities, as well as policy development. The OPC also intends to reach out to individuals and small and medium-sized enterprises with respect to privacy issues related to cloud computing. The comments related to PIPEDA compliance will also be considered in any review of the legislation.
Monday, April 18, 2011
Cloud Computing and Privacy FAQ
Is it illegal for a Canadian business to outsource services, such as cloud computing, to a non-Canadian company?
Is it illegal for a Canadian public sector or government body to outsource services, such as cloud computing, to a non-Canadian company?
What is all the fuss about privacy and cloud computing?
What does British Columbia’s anti-export law say?
What does Nova Scotia’s anti-export law say?
Is information better protected from law enforcement and national security access in Canada than in the United States?
Does keeping data in Canada keep it away from American law enforcement and national security agencies?
If we go with a cloud solution, should we give notice of this to our customers/users?
What are the legal security requirements for Canadian companies considering cloud computing?
What role should jurisdiction play in a decision about whether to adopt cloud computing?
What should I be looking for in the contract with my service provider?
What are the best practices for decision-making around cloud computing?
About the author
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
University of Alberta on Google goes live
The Official Google Enterprise Blog announces today that the University of Alberta is about to flick the switch to "Go Google" for student e-mail. The remaining faculty and staff will be switched over in the next months. This has been closely watched by most other Canadian universities as they look at cloud computing to cut IT costs and to provide more tools to students, faculty and staff. See: Official Google Enterprise Blog: The Green and Gold Goes Google.
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Dalhousie University's cloud conversation
Over the last few months, Dalhousie University has been looking much more closely to the possibility of replacing much of its expensive infrastructure with an outsourced cloud service. I was part of the conversation with my presentation (large mov file) on campus on Data Privacy Day and the conversation has been continuing. It has been very interesting to look at three recent articles on Dal News, including a two-part interview with Dwight Fischer, the University's CIO, and particularly the comments by students and other stakeholders on those articles. Check them out:
- dalnews.dal.ca - Looking to the cloud
- Q & A with Dwight Fischer (Part I)
- Q & A with Dwight Fischer - Continuing the Cloud Conversation (Part II)
If you are a member of the University community (have a dal.ca login), you can join the conversation here: https://blogs.dal.ca/connectedU/.